Here is my mess of a list. It exists with no formula other than it looked good on the page. Top 10 are ranked, followed by the remaining 90 in alphabetical order. Excuse the overlap with Scott's list... we dig a lot of the same movies. If it's on the list, it's totally rentable.
TOP 100
1. Unbreakable
Are you unbreakable?
2. Artificial Intelligence
They made us too smart, too quick, and too many.
3. Memento
Otnemem is the intellectual's Rubik's Cube.
4. Punch Drunk Love
Method to Sandler’s madness.
5. Vanilla Sky
One helluva "it was all a dream".
6. The Royal Tenenbaums
The poetry of people.
7. Zodiac
Climactic anti-climax. Z is for Zaroff.
8. Inglourious Basterds
You know somethin’, Utivich? I think this just might be my masterpiece.
9. Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind
Better to have loved and lost, than to have never loved at all.
10. 25th Hour
F*** this whole city and everyone in it.
11. A Beautiful Mind
12. A History of Violence
13. About Schmidt
14. Adaptation
15. Almost Famous
16. Apocalypto
17. Avatar
18. Batman Begins
19. Bubble
20. Bug
21. Cast Away
22. Catch Me If You Can
23. Children of Men
24. Closer
25. Collateral
26. Crash
27. Death Proof
28. Dogville
29. Elephant
30. Elizabethtown
31. Funny People
32. Gangs of New York
33. Gerry
34. Gladiator
35. Gran Torino
36. Hannibal
37. Hero
38. House of Flying Daggers
39. House of Sand and Fog
40. I Heart Huckabees
41. In Bruges
42. In the Mood for Love
43. Insomnia
44. Into the Wild
45. Jarhead
46. Kill Bill Vol. 1 & 2
47. Knocked Up
48. Lost in Translation
49. Marie Antoinette
50. Match Point
51. Matchstick Men
52. Meet the Parents
53. Million Dollar Baby
54. Minority Report
55. Mulholland Drive
56. Munich
57. Mystic River
58. No Country for Old Men
59. Ocean’s Eleven
60. Old School
61. Oldboy
62. Paranoid Park
63. Rachel Getting Married
64. Requiem for a Dream
65. Revolutionary Road
66. Road to Perdition
67. School of Rock
68. Sideways
69. Signs
70. Sin City
71. Solaris
72. Speed Racer
73. Star Trek
74. Star Wars Attack of the Clones
75. Superbad
76. Synecdoche, New York
77. The Assassination of Jesse James
78. The Aviator
79. The Company
80. The Curious Case of Benjamin Button
81. The Darjeeling Limited
82. The Dark Knight
83. The Departed
84. The Fall
85. The Fantastic Mr. Fox
86. The Fountain
87. The Hangover
88. The Host
89. The Life Aquatic
90. The New World
91. The Polar Express
92. The Village
93. The Wrestler
94. There Will Be Blood
95. Traffic
96. Transformers
97. Up in the Air
98. Watchmen
99. What Lies Beneath
100. Where the Wild Things Are
Last movie Bryan watched: The Straight Story (David Lynch)
